Troubleshooting Your Instructional Coaching, ep. 259

Coaching isn’t supposed to feel like pushing a boulder uphill, but some days, it absolutely does! That’s why in the season six finale of Instructional Coaching with Ms. B, I’m offering ideas for troubleshooting your instructional coaching!
In this episode, I highlight five coaching problems and share proven steps for tackling each one. These challenges come straight from coaches I’ve been working with over the last year. Many are classic issues, but some have gotten a lot bigger over the last few years.
You’ll hear about what to do when teachers aren’t responding to coaching and ways to clarify your role with teachers or principals. I give ideas for bridging professional development (PD) so there are actual shifts in classroom practice and in the data. Plus, I highlight past podcast episodes that can support you as you work through each challenge.
Ready to make your coaching work easier? Listen to the full episode to get the complete breakdown.
Why Now Is the Perfect Time for a Mid-Year Coaching Reset
This episode is part of the mid-year coaching reset mini-series. December is the ideal time to do some deep reflection on your coaching work so far this year. You want to think about what’s working, what’s not working and then develop a plan to address these issues in the new year. With a fresh outlook, you can work on these obstacles before they get bigger and snowball into something much bigger!
5 Common Instructional Coaching Problems
Instructional coaching comes with plenty of challenges, but you don’t have to figure them out alone! I’m here to help! Here are five common coaching problems and practical strategies for handling them.
Problem 1: The Teacher Isn’t Responding to Coaching
One of the common challenges for instructional coaches is working with teachers who aren’t excited about coaching. You’ve put in the effort, kept it positive, shared strategies, and made yourself available. Yet, despite your best intentions, some teachers seem to be dodging you. Their actions say they’re not ready (or willing) to invite you into their classroom.
Don’t give up! Go back to the basics!
Here are a few steps I take when teachers seem uninterested or resistant:
- Introduce your role clearly and repeatedly (in person and in writing). Be sure teachers really understand what you’re there to do. Just know you’ll probably need to do it more than once!
- Examine your coaching relationships through the lens of the “Three C’s”: clarity, consistency, and connection.
- Think about where your relationship needs work and focus there. Sometimes you need to put in the effort to establish trust or repair past misunderstandings.
- Look for coaching opportunities by responding to teacher questions and complaints with support. These are entry points that will get your foot in the door so you can start building rapport. Offer specific, actionable help and give choices instead of leaving it open-ended.
- Use exit tickets after PD to kick off coaching and follow up confidently.
Remember, you can’t control anyone else’s willingness to work with you. All you can do is ensure you’re not the thing getting in the way. If you’ve done all this and there’s still resistance, keep showing up, offer support, and be ready for that teacher when they’re ready for you.
To learn more listen to Episode 253 – Always Be Coaching: How to Leverage Every Interaction
Problem 2: Your Principal Uses You for Things That Aren’t Your Job
Are you being asked to do lunch duty, test administration, or paperwork? This is one of the most frustrating issues faced by coaches. I really think it’s why every coach’s contract states, “other duties as assigned”. When our days are filled with these distractions, it’s hard to show meaningful progress in the areas where we’re supposed to make an impact.
So, what can you do when you’re being pulled in a million different directions (and who isn’t these days)? The first step is to go back to basics and have a frank discussion with your principal about your coaching role. Make sure your job description and goals are defined, and everyone signs off on them.
You can also document where your time is being spent and share it with your admin. Listen to Episode 143 – How to Track Your Coaching Work with Krissy Ogletree Edwards to hear how she documents her time with simple tools like Google Calendar.
You can also connect your coaching wins to your actual work by doing this exercise with your principal. List all the tasks you’ve spent time on recently on the left and the wins you’ve had on the right. Then connect the wins to the activity they came from. You’re going to notice a lot of the tasks on the left side are not responsible for teacher and student growth.
If none of these strategies help, it might be time to bring in central office support to have a conversation with your principal about your coaching responsibilities. Alternatively, you can share a research article with the principal to clarify what instructional coaching should look like. Although I think bringing in an expert is probably best for sticky situations.
To learn more listen to Episode 193 – The Principal’s Role in Instructional Coaching with Nicole S. Turner
Problem 3: Work You Do During PLC Meetings or PD Isn’t Translating to Classroom Practice
I remember spending 90 minutes planning with each grade level when I first started coaching. Then I went to classrooms, and I didn’t see what we worked on being implemented at all. It was so disappointing!
Whenever we see that things are not transferring to the classroom, we’ve got a real bridge issue. We need to be clear about the purpose of PLC or team meetings.
Ask yourself these questions:
- What will teachers walk away with? Do they?
- Is there a bridge built from the meeting to the classroom?
- Is there a clear expectation?
To build a bridge from meetings to classroom practice, you’ll need to identify if the teacher needs more support or more accountability.
If they need support:
- Use model classrooms
- Model using gradual release
- Email picture examples from other classrooms with the learning in place
- Have grade level review sessions – debrief progress and find ways to make the learning work in their classrooms
- Book study
- Classroom visits with feedback
If they need accountability:
- During PLC planning, identify a specific place where the learning will be integrated into the lessons
- Gallery walks during PD session or meeting – each teacher brings an artifact from when they tried it in their classroom
- Classroom visits with feedback
- Require evidence be displayed (hallway, binder, etc.)
- Praise classrooms where you see it happening in a campus email or a campus newsletter
- Incentives (jeans, coupons, prizes)
- Instructional rounds focused on the initiative
- Team decides on an accountability piece for follow-up and brings evidence to the next meeting
To learn more listen to Episode 210 – Why You’re Not Seeing Classrooms Change with PLC Meetings
Problem 4: The Teacher Isn’t Showing Change After Working with the Coach
Another big challenge for instructional coaches is when a teacher shows little or no visible change after working with you. Think about the support you’ve already provided and analyze if you’ve helped the teacher gradually gain confidence with implementation.
When offering strategies and modeling for teachers isn’t enough, try using the gradual release model. Instead of simply modeling, move through the stages just like we do with students: I do, I do with your help, you do with my help, you do. Sometimes teachers need scaffolds to gain confidence and truly take the reins.
You also want to look for systems or routines that will help the teacher sustain the new practices. This may be planning time with a team, visual reminders, or a consistent classroom routine.
To learn more listen to Episode 125 – Gradual Release with Coaching Cycles
Problem 5: Teachers’ Data Is Not Showing Growth
When the data isn’t budging, it’s time to dig into why! Ask yourself these questions to identify what you might need to do differently:
Do you look at data together?
What happens during those data meetings?
Do you know how tests are administered? Are there consistent procedures across the grade level or school?
The difference you see in the data can be pretty shocking. Visit classrooms during test time to observe and discuss procedures. These visits can be quite eye-opening.
Is the test tied to the curriculum? Do the resources teachers have actually prepare kids, or is there a gap?
Sometimes assessments don’t match what’s being taught, or teachers don’t have the materials they need to prepare students. Try to identify any gaps between instruction, resources, and assessments.
Where are students making errors?
Analyze the test together to see what errors kids are making, and then have a conversation about what can be done. Don’t only look at overall percentages. Instead, zoom in on specific items and patterns in student mistakes. This allows you to figure out why they’re having those problems and target instructional support more effectively.
Does the teacher know how to bridge to the test?
This is a skill many teachers are unsure of, and most kids need guidance to transfer their learning to paper-based assessments. We have to help students connect it, and we often have to help teachers as well.
Are teachers using formative assessments regularly?
Test results shouldn’t be a surprise. Formative assessments give you advanced insights into what students are struggling with and allow you to intervene before the big test.
By answering these questions, you and your teachers can develop an action plan to close gaps, improve instructional practices, and finally see that data move in the right direction!
To learn more listen to Episode 171 – Formative Assessment as Data with Steve Ventura
Troubleshooting Your Instructional Coaching
Instructional Coaching is demanding, and there are a lot of challenges! But you don’t have to troubleshoot them alone. Listen to the full episode to get all the strategies for troubleshooting your instructional coaching and how to reset your coaching in the new year!
Topics and Questions Discussed in Episode 259 – Troubleshooting Your Instructional Coaching
- Troubleshooting your instructional coaching
- Why you need a mid-year coaching reset and how to do it
- 5 common instructional coaching problems and proven solutions
- What to do when teachers aren’t responding to coaching
- Best ways to introduce and clarify your role
- Building coaching relationships with teachers using the “3 Cs”: clarity, consistency, connection
- What to do when your principal asks you to do non-coaching tasks
- Strategies for bridging PD and PLC work into the classroom
- Scaffolding teacher learning through the gradual release coaching model
- Using data to guide instructional improvements
- Past podcast episodes to help you overcome these 5 common obstacles
The End of Season 6 of Instructional Coaching with Ms. B
Thank you all for being part of the podcast! It’s hard to believe the show has been going for six seasons already. I appreciate every listener and hope the podcast has been a helpful resource!
We’re taking a short break, but Instructional Coaching with Ms. B will be back in February 2026 for season seven. In the meantime, I’ll be sharing some of the most popular episodes, so be sure to tune in and catch up!
Got feedback, ideas for new topics, or guest suggestions for next season? Visit buzzingwithmissb.com/survey to share them and enter to win a $25 gift card!
Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast so you don’t miss the launch of season seven. I’m excited to come back with fresh strategies, new insights, and lots of real-world coaching support!
Happy coaching and enjoy your break!
Grab the Action Plan Toolkit
Want some help with your mid-year reset?
Grab the Action Plan Toolkit! It’s filled with practical resources that build on what we talked about in this episode. You’ll get tools to help you conduct a needs assessment, set clear priorities, and create a focused plan so you’re not spinning your wheels or just crossing things off an endless to-do list. Instead, you’ll make real progress at your school!
Ready to listen?
This post contains links to products from one or more of our advertisers. This means I may receive commissions for purchases made through links in this post when you click on links to those products. Thank you for your support!
Learn more
- Episode 257 – Mid-Year Reset: Re-Introducing Yourself as a Coach with Chanavia Patterson
- Episode 258 – Evaluating Work to Provide Evidence of Instructional Coaching Effectiveness with Dr. Jana Lee
- Buzzing with Ms. B on Instagram
- Join My Facebook Group: Instructional Coaching with Ms. B
- Free Five-Day Challenge: Coaching Resistant Teachers
- Instructional Coaching with Ms. B Podcast Survey
Helpful Resources
- Instructional Coaching Action Plan Toolkit Binder: Forms, Planners, & Guide on TpT
- Instructional Coaching Action Plan Bundle
- Instructional Coaching Action Plan Bundle – PD, PLC + Coaching Cycle Forms on TpT
- Instructional Coach Binder Megapack – Editable Forms, Calendars, Planning Tools
- Instructional Coaching Binder Megapack – Editable Forms, Documents & Tools on TpT
- Buzzing with Ms. B TpT Store
- The Confident Literacy Coach
Listen on: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite listening app
Thank you for listening to Buzzing with Ms. B: the Coaching Podcast. Want more coaching ideas
Check me out at buzzingwithmsb.com and on Instagram @buzzingwithmsb.
If you love the show, share it with a coach who would love it too, or leave me a review on iTunes! It’s free and it helps others find this show, too. Happy coaching!
Podcast produced by Fernie Ceniceros






